SIPP vs ISA – which is best for you? (2022)

Fact checked icon
Fact Checked.
Updated on
September 13, 2022

In a nutshell

Both accounts are great for different reasons, and you don’t need to pick between them! Use a SIPP for long-term saving and an ISA for short-to-medium term saving. We recommend having both.

Nutty

Saving and investing your money? Great decision. It’s the best way to grow your wealth over time. But which type of investment account is the best way to invest your hard earned money, a self-invested personal pension (SIPP) or an ISA?

Let’s find out. Each account has different benefits and is suited to different types of saving goals – but they’re both great in their own right.

SIPP vs ISA

What’s a SIPP?

A SIPP, which stands for self-invested personal pension, gives you full control over your money in your pension for your retirement, you choose where and when your money is invested.

What is a SIPP?

It’s a type of private pension, so similar to a pension you’ll get from your employer (called a workplace pension), except you don’t have to use your employer's pension provider (the company that looks after your pension) – they can often be expensive with a poor track record of investing money. With a SIPP you get to choose!

Workplace pension vs SIPP

A SIPP is a great addition to a workplace pension, and pretty essential if you are self-employed and don’t have a workplace pension. If you don’t have a pension you might run into financial trouble later in life if you’re going to rely on just the State Pension (it’s far lower than what you need to live comfortably on. At the moment, the full State Pension is £185.15 per week.).

Full new State Pension

Traditionally a SIPP was solely to manage your own investments, such as you deciding which individual stocks and shares to buy (where you own a tiny portion of a company), or investment funds (groups of investments such as a group of different company’s shares) – so you needed to know what you were doing.

 SIPP - manage your own investments

You can still do this, but more recently, you can also let the experts manage your investments through a SIPP too (it’s confusing right?). So you still get the flexibility and control over your pension, but with the support of professionals growing your money. It’s the best of both worlds.

You are able to pay in £40,000 each year or 100% of your salary (whichever is lower). Well, we say pay in, we mean get tax benefits on, you can technically pay in as much as you like, but it’s not a good idea as you’ll then be paying tax on your contributions.

There’s also a lifetime limit of £1,073,100 that you can have in your pension, after that you’ll pay extra tax (25% when you withdraw). This is called your Pension Lifetime Allowance.

Pension - Lifetime allowanace

If you’ve already decided a SIPP is for you, check out our best private pension providers UK

Still want to know more about a SIPP? Read on…

Free government bonus

Let’s rewind for a second, with pensions, the government wants you to have a nice big pension pot by the time you come to retire (so you don’t have to rely on the government too much) – so they let you save your money within a pension before you pay income tax (that’s a tax on your earnings).

With a workplace pension, your money goes into your pension before paying tax, and this is all handled by your employer. 

Workplace pension tax relief

With a SIPP you’ll get the same tax free saving benefits as a workplace pension. Except instead of your money going into your pension before you pay tax, you’ll get taxed as normal through your pay cheque and then the government will refund the tax you’ve paid back into your SIPP, which is all automatically handled by your SIPP provider.

SIPP tax relief

Let’s say you pay £80 into your SIPP, the government will pay £20 into your pension too. It’s a 25% bonus, which works out the same as if you had paid £100 into your pension before you paid tax (as you’d have paid 20% tax on your salary, which gives you £80).

SIPP tax relief example

Higher rate tax payer?

Now it gets even better. If you’re a higher-rate tax payer, (pay 40% tax), or an additional rate tax-payer (pay 45% tax), you’ll get the tax you paid at that rate too!

However, you’ll have to claim this back yourself on your Self Assessment tax return (it’s pretty easy to do).

No inheritance tax

A SIPP is not subject to inheritance tax – so you can pass it down to your family completely as it is when you die. If you die before 75, it’s completely tax free for your family to receive too, but after 75, they’ll have to pay income tax on the amount.

SIPP - No inheritance tax

Withdrawing your money

When it comes to taking your money out of your pension, only the first 25% of withdrawals are tax-free, the rest you pay income tax on (this is true of all pensions, not just SIPPs).

SIPP - Tax-free amount

The amount of tax you’ll actually pay depends on how much you withdraw each year, you may not pay any tax because of your personal allowance. You can earn £12,570 each year and not pay any tax at all. (it’s similar to how your salary works now).

However, don’t let this put you off a SIPP, despite paying income tax, you may still have made more money because of that lovely government bonus that offsets any tax paid.

Benefits of a SIPP

  • Decide how and where your pension is invested
  • You can consolidate (combine) old pensions into a SIPP
  • Have as many SIPPs are you like
  • Get a government bonus (25%) on everything you put in
  • If you’re a higher rate tax payer get 40% back (and 45% for additional rate taxpayers)
  • No inheritance tax (and no income tax paid if you die before 75)

Drawbacks on a SIPP

  • Can’t access money until you turn 55 (57 in 2028)
  • Only the first 25% is completely tax fee, you may pay income tax on the remaining 75%
  • Can only put in as much as you earn per year (up to £40,000)
  • There’s a lifetime limit of withdrawing £1,073,100 before there’s extra tax charges

When to use a SIPP

If you’re saving for retirement, then a personal pension is probably the best option for you. 

However, there’s one caveat, it’s often better to pay more into your workplace pension if your employer is willing to match your contributions and pay more in themselves – we mean more than the legal minimum, which is when you pay in 5%, your employer must pay in 3%.

Workplace pension

For instance, if your employer matched contributions up to 10%, then you should aim to pay in 10% too – as you’re getting a lot of free cash. However, employer contributions above the legal minimum are quite rare.

So, that’s where personal pensions come in – you can keep saving for retirement all by yourself, without the need for an employer, and still benefit from those tax-free savings – with the lovely bonus from the government. 

Plus, you can decide exactly how and where your money is invested.

What’s an ISA?

So what about an ISA then? By an ISA, we mean a Stocks and Shares ISA (ISA stands for Individual Savings Account). It’s an awesome account where everything you put into it, is completely tax-free, forever!

What is an ISA?

However you would have already paid tax on the money you put into your account (as income tax from your earnings, such as a salary). Whereas with a pension you are saving money before you pay tax.

All of the money you make from investing within the account is all yours – there’s no tax to pay on your profits, such as Capital Gains Tax or tax on dividends (profits paid out to shareholders). Pretty great right?!

You are allowed to save up to £20,000 per year across all of your ISAs (called your ISA allowance) – so that’s a Stocks & Shares ISA, Lifetime ISA and a Cash ISA

ISA allowance

Although, unless you are saving for your first home, you’ll probably only want a Stocks & Shares ISA.

If you are saving for your first home, a Lifetime ISA lets you save up to £4,000 per year and gives you a 25% bonus, but it can only be used to buy your first home or accessed after the age of 60. It is not a replacement for a pension. Learn more with our guide: Lifetime ISA vs pension.

Lifetime ISA vs pension

With an ISA, you can invest your money pretty much anywhere, almost all investment companies, for instance a stock broker, will offer an ISA, and companies who manage your investments for you will all have an ISA option.

You can find the best one for you with our best investment platforms UK.

Benefits of an ISA

  • Everything you make is tax-free, forever
  • Withdraw money whenever you like
  • You decide where and how your savings are invested

Drawbacks on an ISA

  • No government bonus on your contributions (25%)
  • Can’t save money before you pay tax (unlike a pension)
  • Limit of £20,000 per tax year
  • You’ll pay inheritance tax (unless left to a partner)

When to use an ISA

An ISA is great to use for savings goals that aren’t retirement or very long term, as you can withdraw your cash whenever you like. So, perhaps you’re saving for something else like a nice car (we don't recommend buying an expensive car, keep investing if you can and make more money!), or are sensibly letting your savings grow over time by investing them, but still want access if you need it.

When to use an ISA

Not paying tax on the money you make can make a big difference, especially when your savings start growing to large amounts – you’ll end up paying a big chunk in tax if it’s not inside an ISA (or pension), when you sell an investment.

Outside of an ISA, you’ll have to pay Capital Gains Tax on all profits you make above £12,300 per tax year (April 6th to April 5th the following year). And expect to pay around 20%.

Note: accounts that aren’t an ISA are called a General Investment Account (GIA).

SIPP vs ISA

So which is best for you?

They’re two different accounts, both with a massive benefit – growing your money over time without paying any taxes!

Not paying tax makes a huge difference on how fast your money can grow due to something called compound interest – which is where the money you make starts making you money too, and so on and so on, and this cycle continues over time, making you a lot more money.

SIPP and ISA compound interest

However, you don’t need to think which one is better, they’re both suited for different types of saving.

A personal pension is far better for long term saving. You’ll get a 25% bonus on everything you put in, which can increase to 40% or 45% if you’re a higher rate or additional rate tax-payer. That’s a very big deal!

Just make sure you are prepared to lock your money away until you’re at least 55 (57 from 2028).

If you’re not happy to lock your money away for a long time, that’s when an ISA comes in. 

An ISA is great for short-to-medium term saving, as you can withdraw it whenever you like, and everything you make is tax-free! We recommend having both so you can have the best of both worlds. 

So quick recap, SIPP for long-term saving, and an ISA for short-to-medium term saving. And you can have both!

Here’s where to find the best self-invested personal pensions and the best investment platforms for ISAs.

Trophy icon

Rating:

Trophy icon

Rating:

Trophy icon

Rating

Trophy icon

Rating

Trophy icon

Rating

Trophy icon

Rating

Fact checked icon
This article has been fact checked

This article was written by the team at Nuts About Money, and fact-checked by 2 independent reviewers. You’re in safe hands.

Best SIPP providers

Ready to get started with an SIPP? Here's the best options for you.

Best SIPP providersBest SIPP providers

Free monthly money saving email

Get the latest deals, guides and loopholes straight to your inbox, free!

Related articles