Stocks & Shares ISAs: find the best for you

Fact checked
Fact Checked.
Updated on
April 20, 2022

In a nutshell

Stocks and Shares ISAs are a kind of savings account where your money gets invested in successful, or likely to be successful, companies via the stock market, rather than kept as savings in the bank. It's safer than it sounds, easy, and all handled by experts. Best of all, it makes way more cash in the long term.

Nuts About Money squirrel

Let’s talk about Stocks and Shares ISAs. The best (and super easy) way to grow your money over time. Don’t worry if you don’t know anything about stocks and shares, you don’t actually need to know anything to enjoy the huge benefits – it’s all managed by experts for you.

By putting your head-earned dough into a Stocks and Shares ISA, it’ll make you a lot more money in the long-term than any other savings account. Interested? Let’s go through everything you need to know and how to get started.

If you just want to know the best Stocks & Shares ISAs, skip ahead here.

What is a Stocks & Shares ISA?

What is an ISA? And why are a Stocks & Shares ISA so unique? Well, ISA stands for ‘Individual Savings Account’, and it’s a savings account with one massive benefit – you don’t pay any tax at all when your money grows.

ISA Individual Savings Account

Let’s explain the basics…

Usually, if the money in your bank account earns interest, the government counts it as income (i.e. money you earn) and you have to pay tax on it. 

With normal savings accounts, that aren’t ISAs, you pay tax every year on interest over £1,000 if you’re a basic-rate taxpayer (earning between £12,571 and £50,270 per year) and on interest over £500 if you’re a higher rate taxpayer (earning £50,271 or more). These limits are your Personal Savings Allowance (PSA)

However, to encourage saving, UK residents get an annual ISA allowance, which means that you can put a certain amount into ISAs each year without paying any taxes at all on the extra money these accounts make. How good is that?! This allowance is currently £20,000.

ISA allowance 2022-2023

You can put your savings into one ISA, or split it across different kinds of ISAs, such as a Cash ISA or a Lifetime ISA (more on this later). Here’s more about all the different types of ISAs.

How is the Stocks and Shares ISA different from other ISAs?

Firstly you can make a lot more money with a Stocks and Shares ISA than you can with any other type of ISA. How come?

With a Cash ISA (a type of ISA where you just save your money and it makes interest), the ISA provider (that’s the company who manages your ISA, for instance a bank), will decide the interest rate you get, and at the moment these are terribly low, meaning your money doesn’t grow much in your account, currently the best you’ll find are between 1% and 1.75% per year, but most are a lot less.

However, with a Stocks and Shares ISA, where your money is invested by experts, your money grows based on how things are going with the stock market – such as businesses becoming more valuable. Over time this makes you way more money (and we mean waaay more).

Stocks and Shares ISA vs Cash ISA

Explainer: Stock markets are where stocks and shares (very small ownership stakes in companies) are bought and sold around the world. Generally, if the companies that you invest in do well, the value of those shares go up. When you come to sell them in the future, you will get more back than you invested in the first place. 

Imagine it like this: Your regular Cash ISA or savings account is like a safe kept with an ISA provider. It’s yours, and you can either put more money into your safe or take it out when you need to.

With a Stocks and Shares ISA, you still give your money to your ISA provider, but instead of keeping it locked in a safe, they make sure it gets invested smartly in the stock market. It’s all handled by experts that know how to grow money safely over time, so you don’t have to do anything.

When you put more money into your Stocks and Shares ISA, you’re asking your ISA provider to invest (buy) more. When you take your money out of your account, your stocks and shares are sold and you get the money they make from selling them. 

And there’s an extra financial bonus when it comes to Stocks and Shares ISAs:

If you owned shares in a company and they grew in value, you’d have to pay something called Capital Gains Tax. That’s because the extra money (or capital) you make is growing (or gaining) – in other words, money you’ve made. But, if you’ve put money into the stock market through a Stocks and Shares ISA and your investment grows (hopefully by a lot!), you don’t have to pay this, or any tax at all.

Stocks and Shares ISA - Capital Gains Tax

How does a Stocks & Shares ISA work?

When you put your money into a Stocks and Shares ISA, you’re not strictly saving — you’re investing. This means your cash is used by your ISA provider for investments in:

  • Stocks and shares, which are ownership stakes of individual companies. These are bought and sold (called traded), and typically grow in value when a company does well, and the value of the company increases.

  • Bonds, which is letting companies or governments borrow your money. You earn money when that loan is repaid with interest (when the bond ‘matures’). Similar to when you borrow money from the bank and you pay interest.

  • Property, which for ISA investments is often investing in commercial property, like office buildings, shop etc.

  • Exchange-traded funds (ETFs), which can be a combination of all the above, or more commonly just a group of shares. They are often a group of businesses in a similar industry, or a group of large successful businesses, such as the top 100 companies in the UK. You can then buy a share in the fund, rather than all the shares individually. And, these are traded on stock exchanges too, just like shares.

What can I earn from a Stocks & Shares ISA?

The average returns on a Stocks and Shares ISA recently hit 13% per year. If you’d invested your full £20,000 that year, you may have been up £2,600. That’s wildly different from a Cash ISA, which would have made you at best £350, if you had the best interest rate of 1.75%.

Bear in mind that even if your returns aren’t quite this high, you’ll still come out with a really healthy payback over the course of 5-10 years, 8% per year on average is often used as a rule of thumb. Stocks and Shares ISAs are a long-term play, so even if the stock market fluctuates, you’ll ride it out and should come out on top. 

Put simply: you can’t guarantee how much you’ll earn from a Stocks and Shares ISA, but it’s fair to say that it’s likely to be a heck of a lot more than you would earn with a Cash ISA.

Who can open a Stocks and Shares ISA?

If you’re a UK resident over 18 years old, or a crown employee living/working abroad (for example, if you’re in the armed forces), you can open a Stocks and Shares ISA.

You don’t have to pass an economics exam, or bring a list of stocks and shares yourself (although some ISA providers let you choose exactly where to invest your money – for example Freetrade). And you don’t need to check how the stock market does each day.  It’s all handled for you by experts. You can just sit back, relax and watch your money grow over time.

Is my money safe in a Stocks and Shares ISA?

Your money is extremely safe in any type of ISA. If your ISA provider goes out of business (which is extremely rare of course), you’re protected up to £85,000 by something called the Financial Services Compensation Scheme. That means you get everything up to £85,000 back.

The money you invest can go up and down with this kind of ISA. This is the reason why Stocks and Shares ISAs make most sense when you want to set your money aside for 5 years or more, because over time there will be more ups than downs. This means you’ll ride out the bumps. 

The types of Stocks and Shares ISAs

There’s only 2 main types. You can go for an ISA managed completely by the experts, you just sit back and watch your money grow. Or, you can opt for a ‘do-it-yourself’ Stocks and Shares ISA, where you’d pick the investments you want to make.

If you’re a beginner to Stocks & Shares ISAs, go for an expert-managed ISA. And, even if you’re a savings pro, it’s often best to use an expert-managed ISA too – let the experts do all the work, you just sit back and relax.

If you wanted more control over your investments, such as buying shares in a specific company or a specific fund, then a self-managed ISA might suit you better.

Let’s get into each type a bit more…

Expert-managed Stocks & Shares ISAs

These are your ‘standard’ Stocks and Shares ISAs, and if you’re new to investing these are the ones for you. All you need to do is add money!

The ISA provider you choose will work with an investment fund and those experts will take care of everything related to how and where your money is invested – which will normally be invested in shares across a wide range of large, successful companies normally via funds (exchange-traded funds, ETFs).

With some ISA providers, to make things even simpler and cheaper, you can opt for a ‘robo-advisor’. This is where the computers take over, and determine which companies and funds your money is invested in. Don’t fear though, they’re actually really good at making money!

Here's our recommended expert-managed Stocks & Shares ISAs.

Self-managed Stocks & Shares ISAs

Think of yourself as a pro? Know your Apples from your Blackberrys? Or maybe, you’re ready to learn a bit more about investing.

A self-managed ISA gives you control of your money so that you can manage it all yourself – that means choosing, buying and selling investments.

You won’t be using the same ISA provider as an expert-managed ISA, you’ll need one that acts as a broker, which is a company that buys and sells stocks and shares for you from stock markets around the world.

Here's our recommended self-managed Stocks & Shares ISAs.

Ethical Stocks & Shares ISAs

There’s also an increasing variety of Ethical Stocks & Shares ISAs out there. Investing in an ethical ISA means you know your cash won’t be invested in companies that damage the environment (so no oil companies etc), treat their workers badly, or take part in any other nasty shenanigans. It’s definitely the way forward to a healthier future, and the investment returns are just as good, in fact often better!

How to get a Stocks & Shares ISA

Opening a Stocks and Shares ISA is not so different from opening any typical savings account.

To get started, you’ll typically apply and manage everything directly from an app on your phone or through a website – it’s really as simple as that. You just download the ISA providers app, or head to their website and get started (our recommendations are below).

Plus you can use the app or website to get full transparency of your money, whenever you like, with up-to-date balances, and without ever having to speak to anyone (unless you want to of course!).

Once the account is set up, you simply transfer some money into it and you’re all set. We’d recommend you also set up a regular automatic payment into the account too (also known as a standing order) – you’ll be surprised how quickly your money builds up.

We’ve also done the hard work researching the best ISAs for you too, here you go…

The best Stocks & Shares ISAs

Recommended expert-managed Stocks & Shares ISAs

Let the experts handle everything, you just sit back, relax and watch your money grow.

Trophy icon
Popular

Nutmeg

Nutmeg's investment track record is good, and it’s simple to set up and manage your money. Just sit back and watch your money grow.

Rating:

Nutmeg rated 4 stars

There's currently a deal for our readers: get your first 6 months with Nutmeg fee-free!

Trophy icon
Best overall

Moneyfarm

Moneyfarm is like a financial advisor on your phone (or website), their experts will work with you to determine the best investment strategy. It’s low cost, with an excellent investment track record and great customer service.

You’ll pay one simple fee that decreases the more you save.

Fees: low (0.35% to 0.75%)

Rating:

Moneyfarm rated 5 stars
Trophy icon

Rating

Recommended self-managed Stocks & Shares ISAs

Take control and manage your own investments – from picking individual stocks to finding new growth funds. The power is in your hands.

Trophy icon
Best overall

Trading212

Trading212 is a platform built for everyone in mind, it’s great for beginners to get started, and perfect for experienced investors too with a huge range of investment options.

It’s also the cheapest platform out there, completely commission free, and the lowest fees on buying foreign stocks.

Rating

Trophy icon
Stocks & Shares ISA

Freetrade

Freetrade are taking the UK by storm and fast becoming one of the top places to buy and sell (trade) stocks and shares for free. The range of investment options is huge, including US and European stocks. An ISA costs just £3 per month and you can manage everything from an app on your phone.

Rating

Freetrade rated 5 stars

There's currently a deal for our readers, get a free share worth up to £200 when you sign up with Nuts About Money.

Trophy icon
Cheapest (ETFs only)

InvestEngine

InvestEngine is great for investing in exchange-traded funds (ETFs), and that’s all they do. It’s a cheap way to invest your money, in fact the only cost you’d pay is the fund fee. There’s no InvestEngine fees.

The great is app to track your investments too.

Rating

InvestEngine rated 5 stars

How much does a Stocks & Shares ISA cost?

The fees on Stocks and Shares ISAs can sometimes be a bit confusing. This is because there tends to be a mixture of different fees for the different services.

But don’t worry, they’re typically all rolled into one fee that the ISA provider will sort out automatically, which will come from your investment. And it’s not often a lot of money, you’ll still be making a lot more than other savings accounts even with this fee.

The fees involved are often:

  • Admin fees (or platform fees). These are charged by your ISA provider, either as a fixed amount on a monthly basis (e.g. £3) or as a percentage of the amount you have in your ISA (around 0.3%).
  • Fund charge, which is the investment fund who manages the actual investments. These are low, often around 0.2%.
  • Trading fees and dealing charges. If you use a self-managed ISA, you might be charged when you buy and sell a share, which are often a flat fee per trade that can range from around £0 to £15, depending on who the ISA provider is.

Overall, these fees are pretty low and not much for the amount of money you could make. Let’s say you’ve invested £20,000 and it’s grown by 13%. You now have £22,600 in your ISA. If your fee is 0.3%, that’s an annual fee of just £67.80. 

Withdrawing your money

Practically, making a Stocks and Shares ISA withdrawal is almost as simple as taking money out of your bank. Just hit withdraw on the app or website. The only difference is it could take a few days to land in your bank account. Why? Your ISA provider will need to sell your investments, which can take a few days.

However, always try and play the long game with a Stocks and Shares ISA, and try not to withdraw your cash unless you really need it – that way you’ll be making more money over time.

Alternatives to a Stocks & Shares ISA

Stocks and Shares ISAs have the potential to make you a lot of money, and while they’re really accessible and less risky than you might think, you still might not feel like a Stocks and Shares ISA is for you right now.

Or, you might not be fully convinced yet – you could invest a little in a Stocks & Shares ISA and the rest in another savings account.

That’s ok. There are lots of other options out there:

Cash ISA

A Cash ISA will give you interest on your savings, just like a regular savings account, but with the benefit of the interest being completely tax-free. However, currently interest rates are very low. For example, the very best you’ll get is a 5-year fixed-rate deal that gives you a 1.75% interest rate. So if you invested £5,000, you’d have around £5,450 at the end of the five years.

Lifetime ISA

If you’re saving for your first home, you could opt for a Lifetime ISA. With this, the government will top up your savings by a massive 25% each year. 

Lifetime ISA (LISA) bonus

If you add £4,000 per year (the maximum allowed), that’s an additional £1,000. Amazing! The only downside is that you get a 25% penalty if you withdraw your money for any other reason than a first house deposit or after you’re 60 years old.

But it gets even better – you can get a Stocks & Shares Lifetime ISA, which means you get all the long term saving benefits of stocks and shares, with the additional 25% bonus on all the money you put in. Winning!

The alternative Lifetime ISA you could opt for is a Cash Lifetime ISA, which would give you interest on your money (similar to a Cash ISA), with the added bonus of 25% extra free!

Now, get saving!

Stocks and Shares ISAs are really easy to set up, and you’ll make a lot of money in the long-term – totally tax-free. There’s no time like the present, check out our recommendations to find the right Stocks & Shares ISA for you, and get saving today!

Fact checked
This article has been fact checked

This article was written by the team at Nuts About Money, and fact-checked by 2 independent reviewers. You’re in safe hands.

Here for the best Stocks & Shares ISAs?

Skip straight to our recommendations and you'll be up and running in no time.

View recommendationsView recommendations

Free monthly money saving email

Get the latest deals, guides and loopholes straight to your inbox, free!